Agent Team 02 6152 8374 Book an appraisal

Home/Blog

Buying Guides · 17 October 2024

What to Do When a Seller Says “Make Me an Offer”

Hearing “Make me an offer” in a seller’s market doesn’t mean you should go low. Learn how to navigate this situation and make a strategic offer with advice...

What to Do When a Seller Says “Make Me an Offer”

Even in a strong seller’s market, a homebuyer might hear the words, “Make me an offer.” For a nicely appointed home that is well priced, this can be a surprise. Being invited to write an offer

Even in a strong seller’s market, a homebuyer may hear the phrase, “Make me an offer,” which can catch them off guard, especially if the home is well-priced and in good condition. This might make a buyer pause and wonder if there’s something wrong with the property that’s not immediately obvious. Is there an issue that’s causing the home to linger on the market?

While there’s a chance that the home has a hidden problem, the most likely explanation is that the seller is simply motivated to move. They could have already found another property, be relocating for work, or they may be tired of the ongoing hassle of keeping the home ready for showings. In any case, the seller is signalling that they are ready to move forward.

When a buyer hears “Make me an offer,” the initial assumption might be that it’s an invitation to submit a lowball offer. The thought process often goes: "If the seller is eager, maybe they’ll take any offer just to close the deal." However, this can be a risky move.

It’s essential for buyers to listen to their real estate agent, who can provide valuable context and help guide them towards a fair and strategic offer. While the seller may be motivated, it doesn’t necessarily mean they’ll accept a price below market value. Offering too low can insult the seller and may lead to them rejecting the offer entirely, which could cause the buyer to miss out on an otherwise desirable property.

Real estate transactions are emotional for both parties. Buyers want to secure a good deal, and sellers are keen to finalise the sale, but substantial discounts are rare in hot markets. Instead of assuming the seller will accept any price, buyers should assess the situation carefully and rely on their agent's expertise.

The best course of action when hearing, “Make me an offer,” is to take a measured approach. Consider the value of the home, the seller's motivations, and consult with your agent to craft a reasonable offer that meets the needs of both parties. This way, you can increase your chances of securing the home without jeopardising the negotiation process.

Next step: Buying in Canberra? Our free Buyers Course covers pricing, offers and negotiation in plain English.

Free Home Seller's Guide

Not ready to talk yet?
Read this first.

Our free Home Seller's Guide is the advice we give clients every week, in one 32-page guide: costs, timing, pricing, preparation, choosing an agent, negotiating and the legal steps. We'll drop a printed copy to your door, or you can read the PDF online straight away.

32 pages · 10 chapters · Free, no obligation

Book an appraisal

Thinking of selling?
Start with strategy.

An Agent Team appraisal is not just a price on a page. It is a tailored sales strategy session for your home, free and with no obligation. Here is what you walk away with.

Likely price rangeBacked by recent sales near you, not an online estimate.
Best method of saleAuction, private treaty or pre-market, and why.
Preparation adviceWhat to fix, style or leave, and what it costs.
TimingWhen to launch, and how to line up your next move.
Marketing directionWhere your buyers are and how we reach them.
Pre-market optionsTesting demand with our database before launch.
Your net resultCommission, marketing and costs laid out clearly.
Next stepsA written proposal to read in your own time.

Or call the office on 02 6152 8374. Choosing an agent is easy: meet the A Team.

Call usBook an appraisal